石油化工设备技术 ›› 2020, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (6): 6-11.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-8805.2020.06.002

• 静设备 • 上一篇    下一篇

中美规范大型储罐外压失稳设计对比分析

黄泽,王超,杨明翰,金斌戈,刘晓华,刘延雷   

  1. 杭州市特种设备检测研究院,浙江 杭州 310051
  • 收稿日期:2020-03-19 接受日期:2020-10-25 出版日期:2020-11-23 发布日期:2020-11-23
  • 作者简介:黄泽,男,2013年毕业于浙江大学化工机械专业,硕士,主要从事承压设备、大型储罐方面的研究工作,工程师。Email:hz3.14@163.com

Comparative Analysis on Chinese and American Codes for Large Storage Tanks on Instability Design under External Pressure

Huang Ze, Wang Chao, Yang Minghan, Jin Binge, Liu Xiaohua, Liu Yanlei   

  1. Hangzhou Special Equipment Inspection Institute, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, 310051
  • Received:2020-03-19 Accepted:2020-10-25 Online:2020-11-23 Published:2020-11-23

摘要: 在设计真空压力及风压作用下,大型储罐易发生失稳失效,工程中常设置加强圈(或抗风圈)来提高罐壁稳定性。文章着重比较了中美设计规范中大型储罐罐壁的外压失稳公式。研究表明:对常压储罐,中美规范中罐壁外压失稳判定依据均基于短圆筒最小临界压力理论公式推导而来,其中美国规范考虑了形状偏差,国内规范未考虑该因素;对外压储罐,中美规范中罐壁外压失稳校核公式中风压选取基准不一致,且中美规范均未考虑地面粗糙度(或地貌类别)和罐壁高度因素的影响,建议标准修订时考虑该因素。

关键词: 大型储罐, 加强圈, 风载荷, 真空, 外压, 稳定性, 临界压力

Abstract: Under the action of design vacuum pressure and wind pressure, large storage tanks are prone to instability and failure. So reinforcing rings (or wind girders) are usually set to improve the stability of the oil tank walls. This paper focuses on comparing the instability formulas under external pressure for large storage tank walls in Chinese and American codes for design. Researches show that for atmospheric storage tanks, the basis for determining the instability of the tank walls under external pressure in Chinese and American codes is based on the theoretical formula for minimum critical pressure in short round cylinders. Shape deviation was considered in American design codes, while it was not consi-dered in domestic codes; for large storage tanks under external pressure, the wind pressure selection criteria for instability check formula of tank walls is inconsistent; both Chinese and American codes have not taken the factors of ground roughness (or landform category) and tank wall height into consideration. This paper proposes to take such factors into account when revising the relevant clauses in the codes.

Key words: large storage tank, reinforcing ring, wind load, vacuum, external pressure, stability, critical pressure